Wind & Ember
Wind, hurricane & hail

FORTIFIED Roof vs. a Class 4 roof

By Wind & Ember Editorial · Published 2026-11-18

They answer different questions. Class 4 tells you a roofing product survived a steel ball dropped on it in a lab. A FORTIFIED Roof tells you the whole roof was built to resist wind, and that an independent evaluator saw it done.1,8 Plenty of homes need one and not the other.

Hailstones scattered across a wet surface after a storm
Photo: Julia Filirovska / Pexels

Side by side

Class 4 (UL 2218)FORTIFIED Roof
What gets ratedOne roofing productThe finished roof: deck, nails, seams, edges and covering
Main threatHail impactWind uplift and wind-driven rain
The test2-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feetLine-by-line checklist, documented with photos
Who checks your houseNo inspection comes with the ratingAn independent FORTIFIED Evaluator
What you getProduct label and paperworkAn IBHS designation certificate, valid five years

Drawn from GAF's description of UL 2218 and IBHS's FORTIFIED materials.1,2,8

What a Class 4 rating measures

UL 2218 drops steel balls of increasing size from increasing heights onto the roofing. Class 4, the top rating, means the product took a 2-inch ball dropped from 20 feet. Class 3 means a 1.75-inch ball from 17 feet.1

A product fails if it cracks through, checked from the back side. Dents and other cosmetic damage are allowed.1 The test says nothing about how the roof is nailed down, whether the deck seams are sealed, or how it handles wind.

Planning a re-roof? Get bids from a FORTIFIED-certified roofer.

Find a certified pro

Why IBHS says the label isn't enough

IBHS, the insurer-funded lab that writes the FORTIFIED standard, started its own hail tests in 2019 using hailstones made in the lab from measurements and 3-D scans of thousands of real ones. In its first round, eight shingles that all carried impact-resistant labels ranged from Excellent to Poor.5

The November 2025 edition rated 24 products, which IBHS says cover about 95% of impact-resistant shingles sold each year. Most rated Good. None rated Excellent. IBHS buys the shingles at retail, the same way homeowners do.4 Its chief engineer, Anne Cope, put the advice plainly: "If a product rates Marginal or Poor, we do not recommend using it in areas that experience hail."4

What this means when you shop: ask the roofer for the product's IBHS rating, not only its UL 2218 class. Two Class 4 shingles can perform very differently.

What FORTIFIED covers that a shingle can't

Most of a FORTIFIED Roof is under the shingles. The hurricane re-roofing checklist calls for 8d ring-shank nails every 6 inches into the deck, a sealed deck by one of three methods, drip edge nailed every 4 inches, and starter strips set at the edges.2 The shingles themselves must be wind-rated, ASTM D7158 Class H or D3161 Class F, which is a different test from UL 2218.2

A certified FORTIFIED roofing contractor does the work, an independent evaluator documents it, and IBHS issues the certificate insurers ask for. The designation lasts five years.8

When you need both

FORTIFIED has a Hail Supplement for places where hail is the bigger risk. If you add it, IBHS requires shingles rated Excellent or Good in its own hail ratings.3 Oklahoma's Strengthen Oklahoma Homes grant requires the hail version.9 With no shingle rated Excellent in the latest round, that means a Good-rated product in practice.4

How insurers treat each

  • Class 4: in Texas, the Department of Insurance says insurers set impact-resistant roofing credits company by company, with Class 4 earning the highest credit.6 GAF cautions that discounts aren't guaranteed and vary by state and insurer.1
  • FORTIFIED: Alabama sets discounts in regulation at 20% to 60% of the wind and hurricane portion of the premium, depending on the FORTIFIED level. In Oklahoma, 11 insurers' FORTIFIED discounts on the wind and hail portion ranged from 3% to 42%.7

Call your insurer before you re-roof and ask what each option is worth on your policy. The answer varies more than the marketing suggests.

What the FORTIFIED part costs

Louisiana's legislative auditor found the FORTIFIED upgrade plus the evaluator came to a median $3,248 on top of a $12,981 code-standard roof.10 State grants of up to $10,000 often cover that difference. See what a FORTIFIED Roof costs or run the calculator.

Our take: on the Gulf and Atlantic coasts, wind is the expensive risk, so FORTIFIED comes first and impact rating is a bonus. Inland in hail country, a Good-rated Class 4 shingle may do more for you than FORTIFIED alone. In Oklahoma and other places with both, the Hail Supplement gets you both in one inspection.

Ready for FORTIFIED Roof bids?

We can connect you with one FORTIFIED-certified roofer that serves your area. If you are using a grant, check its bid and timing rules first.

Find a certified pro

Sources

  1. GAF — Class 4 Roof Shingles (UL 2218 explained)
  2. FORTIFIED Hurricane Re-Roofing Checklist (Smart Home America copy)
  3. IBHS FORTIFIED Home — Hail Protection That Works
  4. IBHS news release: IBHS releases its most expansive impact-resistant shingle ratings to date (Nov 19, 2025)
  5. IBHS news release: Popular shingles rated as "impact resistant" do not perform equally (Aug 6, 2019)
  6. Texas Department of Insurance — Roofing discounts
  7. Resources for the Future, From Risk to Reward: Insurance Discounts for Wildfire Mitigation (WP 25-30, Dec 2025), Section 5
  8. IBHS FORTIFIED Home — Frequently asked questions
  9. Oklahoma Insurance Department, Strengthen Oklahoma Homes column (June 2025)
  10. Louisiana Legislative Auditor, Louisiana Fortify Homes Program, Audit Control #42240005 (March 2025)

Last checked 2026-11-18. Programs and prices change; confirm with the official source before you act.

Find a certified proGrants